Hfea regulations research embryo creation. Medical search. Frequent questions

The recent desperation to clone human embryos may be seriously undermining accepted ethical principles of medical research, with potentially profound wider consequences. (lifeissues.net)
Elsewhere on this site I describe my own conversations with a British scientist in the 1980s who was attempting then to clone human embryos - with some success. (globalchange.com)

The 1990 Act ensured the regulation, through licensing, of: the creation of human embryos outside the body and their use in treatment and research the use of donated gametes and embryos the storage of gametes and embryos. (wikipedia.org)
Not freezing gametes and embryos at all, delaying collection and freezing and failing to build up sufficient reserves of frozen eggs, sperm and embryos can undermine your chances of successful family building. (louisaghevaertassociates.co.uk)
Provide help and assistance with import and export of gametes and embryos. (louisaghevaertassociates.co.uk)

The Regulations were implemented on 1 April 2005 and any donor who donated sperm, eggs or embryos from that date onwards is, by law, identifiable. (wikipedia.org)

Human embryo science: can the world's regulators keep pace? (global-observatory.org)
lt;span class="field field--name-title field--type-string field--label-hidden">Human embryo science: can the world's regulators keep pace? (global-observatory.org)
Last year Advanced Cell Technology (ACT) in the US announced they had successfully made the world's first cloned embryos using human eggs. (globalchange.com)

And I want to make it clear that am unashamedly in favour of the continued importance of a specialist regulator overseeing fertility treatment and embryo research. (hfea.gov.uk)
The HFEA takes seriously our role to provide reassurance about the regulation of fertility treatment and research to ensure public confidence in this is maintained. (hfea.gov.uk)
But as the Chair of the HFEA my dilemma is this: given the extraordinary medical advances and changes in social attitudes to fertility treatment over the last 30 years, how is it possible to regulate effectively with a law that is largely 30 years old? (hfea.gov.uk)
Failing to consider the legal aspects which govern the storage and use of frozen eggs, sperm and embryos in fertility treatment can also create unwanted problems and even prevent their use in treatment. (louisaghevaertassociates.co.uk)
From a legal perspective, it is important to understand and proactively manage the legal terms which govern the storage, control and use of eggs, sperm and embryos in fertility treatment in the UK. (louisaghevaertassociates.co.uk)
Unfortunately, their relationship subsequently broke down and a legal dispute arose between them about the use of those embryos in further fertility treatment. (louisaghevaertassociates.co.uk)
Complex legal issues and problems can also arise in relation to the collection, storage and use of eggs, sperm and embryos in posthumous fertility treatment to preserve biological legacy and honour family building wishes notwithstanding death. (louisaghevaertassociates.co.uk)

Question 1: Do the additional purposes in the 2001 Regulations raise issues of principle different from the purposes specified in the 1990 Act? (cmq.org.uk)
Take the case of Ms Natalie Evans, who in 2001 created and froze six embryos with her partner Mr Howard Johnston in IVF treatment before undergoing treatment for ovarian cancer which left her infertile. (louisaghevaertassociates.co.uk)
This issue was considered by the House of Representatives Standing Committee on Legal and Constitutional Affairs in its report entitled Human Cloning: Scientific, Ethical and Regulatory Aspects of Human Cloning and Stem Cell Research (hereafter the Andrews Report , after the Chair of the Committee, Mr Kevin Andrews, MP) released in September 2001. (edu.au)

In 2004, the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (Disclosure of Donor Information) Regulations 2004/1511, enabled donor-conceived children to access the identity of their sperm, egg or embryo donor upon reaching the age of 18. (wikipedia.org)
Legal issues and difficulties can also arise in circumstances where people have created embryos overseas with an anonymous donor and then wish to import them into the UK. (louisaghevaertassociates.co.uk)
There is currently no automatic right to import embryos comprising anonymous donor gametes under UK law and you would then need to make an application to the Human Fertilisation and Embryology for special permission to import them. (louisaghevaertassociates.co.uk)
The latest HFEA clinic statistics show that Complete Fertility Centre's 31% donor insemination (DI) success rates are 14% above the national average for patients below the age of 38, and 12% above the national average for patients who are 38 years of age and over. (completefertility.co.uk)

It is a statutory body that regulates and inspects all clinics in the United Kingdom providing in vitro fertilisation (IVF), artificial insemination and the storage of human eggs, sperm or embryos. (wikipedia.org)
Whilst flash freezing of eggs (by vitrification) has improved the viability of freezing eggs, it is important to remember that not all eggs will survive the freezing and thawing process and further losses can be experienced in the creation of embryos. (louisaghevaertassociates.co.uk)

The Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA) is an executive non-departmental public body of the Department of Health and Social Care in the United Kingdom. (wikipedia.org)
It also regulates human embryo research. (wikipedia.org)
citation needed] The 1990 Act provided for the establishment of the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA), an executive, non-departmental public body, the first statutory body of its type in the world. (wikipedia.org)
The HFEA is the independent regulator for IVF treatment and human embryo research and came into effect on 1 August 1991. (wikipedia.org)
In the UK it is against the law under the Medicines for Human Use (Clinical Trials) Regulations 2004 to start, recruit to or conduct a clinical trial of an investigational medicinal product (CTIMP) until there is a favourable opinion from a recognised REC (and authorisation from the licensing authority the Medicines and Healthcare Products Regulatory Agency MHRA). (imperial.ac.uk)
GTAC is the UK national REC for gene therapy clinical research according to regulation 14(5) of The Medicines for Human Use (Clinical Trials) Regulations 2004. (imperial.ac.uk)
He provides the recent attempt to "future-proof" the UK's Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act (HFEA) as an example, though not one without substantial challenges. (global-observatory.org)
Right To Life UK is calling on the Government to undertake an urgent inquiry to investigate why two bodies who are funded by the UK taxpayer, the Baraham Institute and Sciencewise , are running a 'dialogue project' that is, in reality, a thinly-veiled attempt to lobby for the removal of the 14-day-limit for experimenting on human embryos. (righttolife.org.uk)
As part of its review, the HFEA launched a consultation in which it made a "case for change" to current laws, seeking to extend its powers and expand research using human embryos. (righttolife.org.uk)
Currently, the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act limits the use of human embryos in research to 14 days or the appearance of a primitive streak (if earlier). (righttolife.org.uk)
In the consultation, the HFEA makes the case for removing the 14-day limit from current legislation, outlining the desirability of doubling the existing 14-day age limit during which research on human embryos is permitted. (righttolife.org.uk)
While in the past it was not technically feasible to culture human embryos beyond formation of a primitive streak or 14 days post-fertilisation, culture systems have evolved, now introducing this possibility . (righttolife.org.uk)
The importance of a 14-day limit was further underlined by Dawn Primarolo, a health minister, in her closing of the debate when she emphasised, with regard to human-animal embryos that were a central focus of the 2008 Bill, that "the Bill sets out strict prohibitions to guard against abuses. (righttolife.org.uk)
The HFEA has previously been criticised regarding both its independence, as a regulator, and its impartiality in relation to the ethical standards it is obliged to uphold, which include Parliament's insistence on the " special status " of the human embryo. (righttolife.org.uk)
The number of egg donors is also increased over the past years and according to Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA) women registering as altruistic donors have risen every year since 2006. (ivfclinicsworldwide.com)
Finally, and inexorably, a true professional scientist poses clearly challenging questions to his research colleagues, and to the scientific enterprise in general, about the dubious "scientific" justification for the current rush to clone human beings - for both "therapeutic" and for "reproductive" purposes. (lifeissues.net)
Ethically, since eventually all such "research" will be applied to people, he cautions against the abuse of women "egg" donors, and against the premature use of vulnerable sick human patients for testing supposedly "patient-specific" stem cells in supposed "therapies", pointing to the obvious violations of standard international research ethics guidelines such clinical trials would necessarily entail. (lifeissues.net)
And he also agrees that if we don't find global agreement on human cloning, "we can probably expect dire consequences for the future of biomedical research and its impact on society at large. (lifeissues.net)
But he is equally concerned about the unethical aspects inherent in the rush to perform " therapeutic " human cloning research, including the abuses to all vulnerable human patients who would be required to participate in clinical trials. (lifeissues.net)
As he has questioned the HFEA before, would not the use of vulnerable human patients in clinical trials be premature, dangerous, and unethical given the already acquired knowledge in the research community that such supposed "patient-specific" stem cells would most probably cause serious immune rejection reactions in these patients? (lifeissues.net)
Though the announcement is couched in terms that make it seem humanitarian, as potentially a huge advance in science, an agency tied to the British government is encouraging efforts in gene-editing of the DNA of human embryos. (virutron.com)
The report and the people behind it, including the Government's Medical Research Council, indicate that a major push is underway to convince the public that genetic manipulation of human embryo DNA, so-called gene editing, is desirable and beneficial. (virutron.com)
The issuance of the Nuffield Council on Bioethics report marks a major advance to creation of radical new laboratory interventions into human embryos to create what critics call "designer babies. (virutron.com)
The methodology of manipulating a specific part of a DNA chain to change human embryos is based on flawed scientific reductionism, which ignores the complexity of biophysical reality and of the fundamental laws of nature. (virutron.com)
Now the debate is moving on to gene editing of human embryos. (virutron.com)
Two years ago, researchers in China used human embryos given by donors of embryos that could not have resulted in a live birth, to edit a specific gene. (virutron.com)
The creation of an embryo by nuclear transfer is a human being whose right to continued life should be respected. (cmq.org.uk)
Secondly, widening the scope of research further establishes the human embryo as a mere commodity for use as a research animal and moves away from Dame Warnock's assertion that the embryo deserves special respect. (cmq.org.uk)
Most of the differences between Britain and other countries are due to the lowly status that is afforded the human embryos in this country. (cmq.org.uk)
Britain is almost isolated in Europe in its failure to afford the human embryo any meaningful status, as attested by the huge number of embryos produced and destroyed. (cmq.org.uk)
Following discussions earlier this week, European Union (EU) research ministers have failed to find a majority opinion on how human embryonic stem cell (ES cell) research should be funded under the Seventh EU Research Framework Programme 2007-2013 (FP7). (progress.org.uk)
Other predominantly Catholic European countries ban or restrict the use of human embryos. (progress.org.uk)
The European Parliament's approval of funding for some human embryonic stem cell research reflects inequality in how individual countries recognise fundamental rights, according to a Vatican official. (progress.org.uk)
European Ministers have agreed to fund some human embryonic stem (ES) cell research, in a compromise that bans any work involving the destruction of embryos. (progress.org.uk)
Judging by the successful growth of the combined human-cow clone creation it appears that cow mitochondria may well be compatible with human embryonic development. (globalchange.com)
Some people are very uneasy about creating a human embryo and then dismembering it, however early the stage, to obtain embryonic stem cells from which useful tissues might be grown. (globalchange.com)
Stem cells may be derived from adult tissues but the most potent are extracted from developing human embryos. (edu.au)
Dr Dixon, a leading expert on the ethics of human cloning, described today's news as "totally inevitable", with separate US and Chinese teams also claiming that they have created large numbers of human cloned embryos for medical research. (globalchange.com)
Note: Chinese scientists announced end January 2003 that they had cloned 80 human embryos of which 4 developed far enough to be implanted, before being destroyed. (globalchange.com)
The human cloning laws are still so 'weak' that many couples, Dr Dixon fears, will legally conceive a clone in a country which allows insemination of a cloned embryo before returning to their country of origin for birth. (globalchange.com)
This is a disaster waiting to happen because over 170 nations in the world have yet to outlaw the birth of human clones and many of the others are allowing the creation of human clones so long as they are not put into a woman's womb. (globalchange.com)

This is probably related to the number of embryos transferred to the intended mother's womb. (ivfclinicsworldwide.com)
The experiments have already begun, though researchers rush to stress they are with "donated embryos," not implanted after into the womb of a woman, but killed after several days of lab experimenting. (virutron.com)
The best quality fertilised egg, known as an embryo, is then placed back in your womb. (completefertility.co.uk)

This allows researchers to carry out embryonic stem cell research and therapeutic cloning providing that an HFEA Licence Committee considers the use of embryos necessary or desirable for one of these purposes of research. (wikipedia.org)
On the topic of cloning we should set an example by outlawing it in all its forms, cloned babies and so called 'therapeutic cloning' (which is a misnomer as at this stage no therapeutic benefit will result from the cloned embryo). (cmq.org.uk)

Fertility 2022 - Julia Chain, Chair of the HFEA delivers a speech: 'The HFEA 30 years on - what needs to change? (hfea.gov.uk)

There is a range of different views world-wide on the acceptability of research on embryonic stem cells. (cmq.org.uk)
We still think that adult stem cell research is preferable to embryonic stem cells, but we don't have a qualified majority in favour of this', she said. (progress.org.uk)
Embryonic stem cell technology is still at a preliminary research stage and announcements about its potential may be premature. (edu.au)
Experts from around the world are assessing the difficult issue of the extent to which embryonic stem cell research should be allowed to proceed, and to date there is little international consensus on this matter. (edu.au)
How, then, should embryonic stem cell research be regulated in Australia? (edu.au)
In this article we examine embryonic stem cell research and explore the current regulatory framework associated with this research in Australia, with particular reference to the Andrews Report . (edu.au)

Many of you will know that the HFEA is the first regulator of its kind in the world, and we are recognised as the global gold standard for innovative and effective regulation. (hfea.gov.uk)

The HFEA study which surveyed 1423 egg donors at 60 IVF clinics in 11 European countries, reported that the majority of donors are keen to help infertile couples for altruistic reasons, but a large proportion also expect a financial benefit. (ivfclinicsworldwide.com)
All of our sperm donors are UK-based healthy and fertile men who are screened in line with the HFEA's strict regulations. (completefertility.co.uk)

This irreconcilable conflict between them ultimately resulted in a legal ruling which prevented Ms Evans from using the embryos and their destruction. (louisaghevaertassociates.co.uk)

In the 9 months that I have been HFEA Chair, I have visited some clinics and I have seen first-hand the real positives in the work that you are doing - helping create new families, preventing new generations from suffering severe genetic disease, and supporting ground breaking scientific research. (hfea.gov.uk)
In the Parliamentary debate which preceded the Act becoming law, the Labour health secretary (Alan Johnson), Conservative shadow health secretary (Andrew Lansley), Liberal Democrat health spokesperson (Norman Lamb) and the Chair of the Health Select Committee (Kevin Barron) all referenced the 14-day limit as an important safeguard for embryo research. (righttolife.org.uk)

The intention of Parliament in drawing up the 1990 Act was to totally ban cloning which was then foreseen as transferring a nucleus into an enucleated embryo. (cmq.org.uk)

increase in legislation regulating and inspecting aspects of research has led to concern within the research community. (parliament.uk)
For example, local governments have passed clean indoor air legislation to address tobacco as a health hazard, state courts have upheld vaccination mandates and federal regulations have established vehicle performance crash standards to promote motor vehicle safety. (studylib.net)
The President may bind the U.S. to international treaties and executive agreements that require creation of domestic laws, or that create law that is on par with federal statutes.4 N Legislation. (studylib.net)
In 2004, Italy passed very restrictive legislation on IVF and related technologies, including embryo research. (progress.org.uk)

The pace of scientific development has been directly promoted by substantial increases in OECD (Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development) government funding for genetic and biotechnological research. (edu.au)

Members have other things on their minds today that are perhaps more pressing than what we are discussing today and do not regard regulation as being as important as some of us believe it is. (parliament.uk)
In other research areas, commercial pressures have resulted in a changed culture with regard to scientific announcements. (edu.au)

The focus is use of new technologies for gene editing, including CRISPR-Cas9, to "alter a DNA sequence(s) of an embryo, or of a sperm or egg cell prior to fertilisation. (virutron.com)

reflects on recent developments in embryo research to point to the gap between the pace of scientific research and the abilities of regulatory institutions to keep up with new developments. (global-observatory.org)

Research and development, and the young people whom we train to work in our industries, have made a difference in terms of what we can discover. (parliament.uk)
The extra hormones necessary for the embryo development can also have a positive impact on your well-being and general health condition during and after pregnancy. (ivfclinicsworldwide.com)
The principles of stem cell development and differentiation should be researched in animals. (cmq.org.uk)

People are charged with operating the regulations and drawing them up. (parliament.uk)
Although the issue is a quagmire and many people hate regulation, there is no doubt that it is necessary in many circumstances, mainly because the public expect it. (parliament.uk)
Many people are worried about regulation. (parliament.uk)
There will be a huge explosion of effort in medical research and stimulation, and we do not want that to be inhibited by fearsome regulations that put people off filling in the forms or whatever bureaucracy is associated with such regulations. (parliament.uk)
This is probably not a surprise since that's something that most people are likely to consider if becomes clear to them that egg donation is going to be the only way in which family creation via assisted conception can be possible. (ivfclinicsworldwide.com)

It is clear that medical research has contributed so much not only in this country, but throughout the world. (parliament.uk)

The executive branch (the President, governor, mayor, county executive and agencies such as departments of public health) may issue rules and regulations based on authority delegated by the legislature through statutes. (studylib.net)

Law as a public health tool Legal tools such as statutes, regulations and litigation have played a vital role in historic and modern public health achievements including advances in 2 infectious disease control, food safety, occupational health, injury prevention and emergency preparedness and response. (studylib.net)
Indeed, the reason why UK parliament gave a green light to proceed with legal creation of cloned embryos was because they had been told by British cloners that it was possible and important to do it for medical research. (globalchange.com)

This has led the National Health and Medical Research Council (NHMRC) to publish guidelines on the requirement for appropriate qualifications to scientific announcements to avoid unrealistic expectations in the community for the early introduction of medical products. (edu.au)

This huge and powerful industry is pushing ahead to create large numbers of cloned embryos, despite the fact that the medical benefits may well be overtaken by a much more interesting process, which uses adult stem cells instead. (globalchange.com)

Assisted reproductive technology (ART) and embryo research have posed many challenges to the different timeframes of science, ethics and law. (edu.au)

While welcoming the opportunity to undertake medical research, it must have the freedom to work without unnecessary regulatory burdens. (parliament.uk)
Some EU member states ban ES cell research in its entirety, while others favour a more liberal regulatory approach, allowing such research to take place, but under strict guidelines. (progress.org.uk)

Regulation must be one of the most boring issues in Parliament, yet I hope to prove that many problems are associated with it. (parliament.uk)
Members of the lower house of parliament voted against changing the code, arguing self-regulation by right-to-die organizations such as Exit and Dignitas worked and the liberal rules protected individual freedoms. (blogspot.com)

Jonathan Herring Medical law and related laws 1- Public Health Law (health care law) Definition Public health law or Health care law focuses on the legislative, executive, and judicial rules and regulations that govern the health care industry. (studylib.net)

and "strict regulation and oversight," the report opens a Pandora's box of eugenics issues, the long-standing agenda of circles such as the Rockefeller Foundation, Rockefeller University, Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation and others. (virutron.com)

As part of its case for making this change, the HFEA mentions that the International Society for Stem Cell Research recently proposed new guidelines to remove the 14-day limit on embryo research. (righttolife.org.uk)

Any other good quality embryos that are left can be stored by us for future family building. (completefertility.co.uk)

We want to encourage innovation in research. (parliament.uk)

It exists for the safety of the public in many cases and we must have good regulation if we are to establish new research, new technologies and new ideas. (parliament.uk)

Because of this, a policy on ES cell research that applies to the whole of the EU has proved impossible, particularly as Roman Catholic countries such as Italy or Poland, who traditionally are against embryo research, could block any votes. (progress.org.uk)

Would issues relating to research on embryos benefit from more attention at international level? (cmq.org.uk)

Stem cells from cord blood or adult tissues do not give rise to the same moral considerations as those derived from embryos or cloned embryos or aborted foetuses. (cmq.org.uk)
In order to qualify for research funds, projects must show a need to use ES cells, by establishing that the same research cannot be undertaken using adult stem cells , such as those derived from bone marrow. (progress.org.uk)

The guidance below provides details for the ethics approvals required for different types of projects for research conducted within the UK and therefore governed by UK law. (imperial.ac.uk)
Ethics approval must be sought for all healthcare research within the NHS. (imperial.ac.uk)
And if they don't know them, then even the international research ethics guidelines would preclude them from performing such research. (lifeissues.net)

They took a cell from Dr Jose Cibelli, a research scientist and combined it with a cows egg from which the genes had already been removed. (globalchange.com)

According to the study, single embryos were used in 15 percent of IVF cycles in 2010. (ivfclinicsworldwide.com)

I will concentrate on regulation because it crosses various Departments, especially the Department of Health and the Department of Trade and Industry. (parliament.uk)

Anatomy1

Analytical, Diagnostic and Therapeutic Techniques and Equipment3

Anthropology, Education, Sociology and Social Phenomena1

Humanities1

Information Science1

Named Groups1

Geographicals1

Clone human embryos2

Gametes and embryos3

Donated sperm1

World's3

Fertility treatment7

20013

Donor4

Eggs2

Human41

Womb3

Therapeutic2

20221

Embryonic6

Regulator1

Donors2

Destruction1

Chair2

19901

Legislation4

Genetic1

Regard2

Gene1

Reflects1

Development3

People5

Country1

Authority1

Legal2

National1

Create1

Science1

Regulatory2

Parliament2

Legislative1

Strict1

Society1

Family1

Innovation1

Public1

Policy1

Issues1

Stem cells2

Ethics3

Scientist1

Study1

Departments1