Comments peer reviewed. Medical search. Frequent questions

GAO supports the AICPA's initiatives to enhance the peer review process by incorporating best practices of effective peer reviewers into the peer review standards and improving audit performance. (gao.gov)
Reviewers not only help to select the content to be published but also are expected to provide meaningful comments that can improve the quality of the manuscripts they review. (psychologicalscience.org)
By incorporating reviewers' comments and suggestions, authors can improve their manuscripts and even develop new research ideas. (psychologicalscience.org)
Peer review sustains science," Goldstone added, noting that reviewers should make their reviews as helpful as they can. (psychologicalscience.org)
Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) provides ethical guidelines for peer reviewers. (psychologicalscience.org)
Publons allows reviewers to track their peer review contributions. (psychologicalscience.org)
These individuals send their reviews to the Action Editor, who then makes the decision to accept the manuscript, reject it, or ask the authors to revise it, taking into account the reviewers' and editor's comments before resubmitting it. (psychologicalscience.org)
In offering additional advice to peer reviewers, Tone suggested starting young and reviewing as often as you can, to benefit not only the field but also reviewers themselves. (psychologicalscience.org)
Is this work interesting enough or potentially interesting enough to send out to members of the scientific community for peer review and typically three reviewers will write comments about the paper send it back to the editors and a decision is rendered. (thenakedscientists.com)
So to try to get beyond that we looked at how successful men were when reviewed by all male reviewers versus reviewers of mixed gender and how successful they were when reviewed by reviewers from the U.S. versus other countries. (thenakedscientists.com)
While I am sure there is room for improvement, and a need for de-"elitizing" the peer review process, I believe that the editor's task of choosing appropriate reviewers is an essential part of maintaining a high quality journal. (historians.org)
According to the subtitle, "High-profile researchers say the small-brained Homo naledi exhibited advanced behaviours such as burials, but peer reviewers say there's no evidence. (sott.net)
To this end, an important part of peer review is to make sure the publication of the study includes all the detail on methodology and data that others might need to replicate the results (which is something climate reviewers are particularly bad at ). (coyoteblog.com)
Then, and now, these data truly demonstrate how you, our peer reviewers, are the lifeline of the scientific process. (nih.gov)
During 2014 nearly 24,000 reviewers participated in more than 2,500 peer review meetings to assess the scientific and technical merit of NIH applications, and many of those reviewers participated in multiple meetings. (nih.gov)
So with service in mind, today we published an NIH Guide Notice reiterating our expectation that NIH-supported PIs will serve as reviewers when asked and calling on awardee institutions to encourage their researchers in accepting invitations to serve on peer review and advisory groups. (nih.gov)
Papers and reviewers are matched based on their relative rankings: A paper with an estimated rating of N should be reviewed by reviewers whose review qualification level is N-1, N or N+1. (lse.ac.uk)
Our peer review system is based on a partnership between NIH staff and our reviewers. (nih.gov)
Both reviewers and NIH staff follow the policies and procedures that are in place to ensure that every application receives a fair, equitable, timely and unbiased review. (nih.gov)
He added that peer review was too slow, expensive and burdensome on reviewers' time. (timeshighereducation.com)
Opposing him, Georgina Mace, professor of biodiversity and ecosystems at University College London, conceded that peer review was "under pressure" due to constraints on reviewers' time and the use of publications to assess researchers and funding proposals. (timeshighereducation.com)
It seemed to her that the "limiting factor" on effective peer review was the availability of good reviewers, and more attention needed to be paid to increasing the supply. (timeshighereducation.com)
By law (the Federal Advisory Committee Act of 1972), peer reviewers advise agencies on the scientific and technical merits of the applications submitted, but do not make the funding decisions themselves. (domesticpreparedness.com)
From fake reviews to biased ones , one of the main arguments for ditching the system is the myth that reviewers can no longer be trusted to give a fair assessment of another scientist's paper. (editage.com)
Double-blind review is often argued as a way to combat unfairness inherent in the current system (where reviewers know the author's name but not the other way around). (editage.com)
If reviewers turn off their video when taking breaks, the Scientific Review Officer assigned to the meeting will know the number of reviewers present at the meeting at any given time. (cdc.gov)
Reviewers see networking opportunities associated with face-to-face meetings as a benefit of participating in reviews. (cdc.gov)
The process allows peer reviewers to read about research before it is generally known and to gain insight into how other scientists write manuscripts and present data. (nature.com)
Editors of EMBO journals encourage senior reviewers to involve trusted early-career lab members in peer reviews, provided that they have done experimentation in the relevant field. (nature.com)
the idea of completeness in philosophical arguments is unattainable, the attempt to be 'rigorous' can lead to a defensive tendency to reduce ambitions and to protect some tiny piece of ground against the possible objections of those closest to oneself in background and outlook (one's natural peer reviewers). (ox.ac.uk)
Peer reviewers not only rate an article's quality, but also make suggestions for improvement. (medscape.com)
I have even been in the "top 10%" of reviewers-an achievement probably more dependent on timely submission of my comments rather than any extraordinary insights. (medscape.com)
Student peer reviewers are usually not expected to correct mistakes, but rather to identify passages that need revision and to discuss with the writer what kind(s) of problem they have identified. (lu.se)

This coming week (19-25 September) is Peer Review Week 2016, an international initiative that celebrates the essential and often undervalued activity of academic peer review. (oup.com)
1 Availab le at http://www.who.int/mental_health/action_plan_2013/en/ (accessed 22 November 2016). (who.int)
2 Availab le at http://www.who.int/nmh/publications/ncd-action-plan/en/ (a ccessed 22 November 2016). (who.int)
3 Availab le at http://www.who.int/disabilities/actionplan/en/ (accessed 22 November 2016). (who.int)
4 Availab le at http://www.who.int/ageing/global-strategy/en/ (accessed 22 November 2016). (who.int)
5 Availab le at http://www.who.int/hrh/resources/globstrathrh-2030/en/ (a ccessed 22 November 2016). (who.int)
6 Availab le at http://www.paho.org/hq/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=11087%3A2015-54th- directing-council&catid=8811%3Adc-documents&Itemid=41537&lang=en (a ccessed 22 November 2016). (who.int)

Since March 2020, all 42 additional review panel meetings have been virtual, either online (VM or Zoom) or telephone. (cdc.gov)

At APS, after an author submits a manuscript, the Editor in Chief determines whether or not it should be considered for possible publication and, if so, assigns the article to a Senior Editor, who assigns and coordinates with an appropriate Action Editor to determine whether the manuscript should be sent out for review. (psychologicalscience.org)
Each manuscript is reviewed by 3 registrants. (lse.ac.uk)
If you agree to review a manuscript, then make sure to read the paper and be constructive with your comments but do not be rude or personally attack the authors. (springernature.com)
Yesterday, I received a request to review a manuscript. (medscape.com)
Indeed, it is an honor to be selected to peer review a manuscript. (medscape.com)

In the APS webinar The Basics of Peer Review , Drew was joined by Becca White, the APS peer review manager, alongside Robert L. Goldstone , editor in chief of Current Directions in Psychological Science , and Erin B. Tone , associate editor for Clinical Psychological Science , to share their experiences involving the process of peer review and tips for engaging in meaningful peer review. (psychologicalscience.org)

The only change in that time has been the decision to send manuscripts "blind" to the board of editors for initial review. (historians.org)
The current view is that arXiv could implement a Community Peer Review model, in which registered readers are allowed to comment and rate manuscripts, which are then collated to form a ranking. (lse.ac.uk)
A registrant can submit several papers per year, but a maximum of six manuscripts will be peer reviewed. (lse.ac.uk)
Associate editors, topical editors, and area editors (referred to here generally as editors) are members of the editorial board of the publication who manage the peer review of submitted manuscripts and ensure that the publication maintains the highest quality while adhering to the IEEE Computer Society's policies and procedures. (computer.org)
All technical manuscripts are submitted through our online peer review system, ScholarOne Manuscripts . (computer.org)
although the formal term of an editor may end according to the calendar, the informal term continues until all manuscripts assigned to that editor have been peer-reviewed and a final decision has been made. (computer.org)
Not all presenters submitted manuscripts, and not all manuscripts were accepted for publication after peer review. (cdc.gov)

ATSDR thanks these scientists for their review of the document. (cdc.gov)
NIH examined the peer review service records of scientists with current research project grant (RPG) support and who have received a total of $1M or more in total costs from NIH in the last 5 years. (nih.gov)
Looking closer at the data, if one day of peer review service per year would be considered a reasonable expectation for service, then currently fewer than half of these funded scientists (45%) achieve that level of service. (nih.gov)
This fish biologist reviews 100 papers per year, but separate studies have shown that political scientists , meteorologists , and nurses review an average 5-8 papers per year. (editage.com)
Her work on beak development in octopus larvae - along with her knowledge, care and keen judgement - had left an impression on scientists in the field and early on in her career, she was invited to become a peer reviewer. (nature.com)
My reading of history is that scientists have been plugging the peer-review mantra because they're tired of having to respond to ignorant assholes who appear on Oprah spouting nonsense. (fieldofscience.com)

Drew and White explained the peer-review process and what happens "behind the scenes. (psychologicalscience.org)

In this post Wang LingFeng discusses how the development of preprint servers as self-organising peer review platforms could be the future of scholarly publication. (lse.ac.uk)
The lack of peer review, is also perceived as making preprint servers harder to use, as finding high quality papers amidst a sea of other papers is a time-consuming, if not impossible task. (lse.ac.uk)

Some humanities journals in recent years have begun experimenting with more open forms of peer review. (historians.org)
In other forms of peer review, scientific content - not just science per se - may be assessed for a particular function, including the likelihood of getting cited. (oup.com)
Given that increasing investment in science globally means ever greater scientific outputs ( particularly across the fast-growing knowledge economies of Asia and Latin America ), all forms of peer review are currently facing limited capacity. (oup.com)

But the process of peer review has been around for centuries, formally and informally, from the Greek Agora to the first Royal Society meetings. (editage.com)

Retraction Watch interviews Adam Day to talk about the identification of fabricated peer reviews and papers. (ahrecs.com)

Look here for a thoughtful discussion of credit for peer review schemes. (editage.com)
It takes me at least 2-3 hours to do a thoughtful peer review, more if I need to consult the literature. (medscape.com)

Now the papers have been published as reviewed preprints in the journal eLife (see here , here , and here ) - alongside peer review. (sott.net)
Preprints - rapidly published non peer reviewed research articles - are becoming an increasingly common fixture in scholarly communication. (lse.ac.uk)
Do preprints need peer review? (lse.ac.uk)
It does not accept Literature Review Articles, Hypothesis Papers, Commentaries, Opinion Pieces, Case Studies, Case Reports etc. which may instead be submitted to PeerJ Preprints . (uncommondescent.com)
Preprints and Citations: Should Non-Peer Reviewed Material Be Included in Article References? (sspnet.org)
While the use of preprints (public posting of an early draft of a paper before it's submitted to a journal for formal review) has long been established in fields like physics and the social sciences, recent uptake in the biomedical world has raised some concerns. (sspnet.org)

It's essentially up there and published, and they can say, 'we have reviewed the reviewer's comments, and we thank them for it. (sott.net)
Non-monetary incentives (e.g. journal subscriptions) might help some people, but probably won't change a reviewer's mind if they don't have time to accept a review request. (editage.com)
Although it is usually not the peer reviewer's task to mark or correct language errors in the text, the following can help you as you review your peers' texts. (lu.se)

Mostly notably, Shakespeare Quarterly ran an experiment a few years ago where they invited a group of experts to post public comments, which authors then responded to. (historians.org)
Brian Lehrer was kind enough to invite me onto his show the other day along with Kathleen Fitzpatrick of MediaCommons and Katherine Rowe, guest editor of the ground-breaking openly peer reviewed issue of Shakespeare Quarterly, to discuss digital scholarship, peer review, and open science. (scienceblogs.com)

It publishes invited target articles by authors from all areas of philosophy, together with invited and open peer commentaries on those invited target articles, and authors' responses to those commentaries. (aap.org.au)
Peer Review Comments and CDC Responses for "Recommendations for Providers Counseling Male Patients and Parents Regarding Male Circumcision and the Prevention of HIV Infection, STIs, and other Health Outcomes" and "Background, Methods, and Synthesis of Scientific Information Used to Inform the 'Recommendations for Providers Counseling Male Patients and Parents Regarding Male Circumcision and the Prevention of HIV infection, STIs, and other Health Outcomes. (cdc.gov)
You must declare any conflicts of interest related to your comments and responses. (medscape.com)

What seems clear to me, as I think about how scholarship and publishing is changing, that regardless of which mode of peer review one favors, what's most important is to keep in mind is the extent to which peer review encourages and develops scholarly conversation in a collegial fashion. (historians.org)
However, unlike traditional scholarly publications, they have not been peer reviewed. (lse.ac.uk)
Richard Smith, who edited the BMJ between 1991 and 2004, told the Royal Society's Future of Scholarly Scientific Communication conference on 20 April that there was no evidence that pre-publication peer review improved papers or detected errors or fraud. (timeshighereducation.com)
1 PeerJ is an Open Access, peer-reviewed, scholarly journal. (uncommondescent.com)

Peer review has two main purposes: (a) to filter out research of poor quality or content that does not fit within the scope of a particular journal, and (b) to improve the quality of journal articles. (psychologicalscience.org)
Content has not been updated since the last reviewed date at the bottom of this page. (cdc.gov)
Planners have reviewed content to ensure there is no bias. (cdc.gov)

The report suggests several models for consideration, placing emphasis on the role of peer support, and its value for NHS England and NHS Trusts. (hepctrust.org.uk)

Read Our Guidelines Trusted peer advice and insights for technology professionals. (gartner.com)

PR8,9,10,11,12,13: The majority of Dr. Hattis= comments (annotated with A#1@ on the peer review report) were concerned with the interaction between atrazine or simazine and nitrate/nitrite to form nitrosoatrazine or nitrososimazine. (cdc.gov)
According to the report, peer mentors have a 'useful role' in supporting vulnerable patients who have difficulties engaging with health services, such as getting to NHS appointments. (hepctrust.org.uk)
It is hugely encouraging to see the report recognise the value of peer support and its role in providing better recovery outcomes for patients. (hepctrust.org.uk)
If you still encounter problems, please report these using the comments and suggestions page. (who.int)

In the discussion that follows, 'PR' refers to the appropriate page of the assembled peer review document, 'P' indicates a page number in the Second Draft of the profile, and '&' indicates the paragraph number on that page. (cdc.gov)
This letter provides the U.S. Government Accountability Office's (GAO) comments on the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants' (AICPA) exposure draft entitled Improving Transparency and Effectiveness of Peer Review. (gao.gov)
Participating governments then provided review comments on the draft, incorporated into the assessment which was presented to seek acceptance at a plenary session of the IPCC. (wikipedia.org)

Perhaps unsurprisingly, the two journals that use blind peer review through the entire evaluation and publishing process scored higher when it came to heterogeneity of institutional affiliations and PhDs of authors, indicating that the practice helps avoid bias. (historians.org)
Seeking practical solutions to some of these concerns, a second survey published this week, this time conducted by PRE (Peer Review Evaluation), a programme of the AAAS, looks at how new developments in peer review might be delivered. (oup.com)
Another peer-review goal is to ensure that the evaluation of grant applications is carried out in a fair and equitable manner and, a third goal, to ensure that the process is free of bias - thus helping the granting agency choose the best application capable of furthering the agency's mission. (domesticpreparedness.com)
Each peer-reviewed Tox Profile reflects a comprehensive and extensive evaluation, summary, and interpretation of available toxicological and epidemiological information on a substance. (cdc.gov)

For example, an earlier survey from Wiley-Blackwell showed that 77% of researchers expressed an interest in peer review training. (oup.com)
Peer review is the backbone of modern science, and academic researchers are expected to participate in the endeavour. (nature.com)
Whether or not they plan to pursue an academic career, junior researchers should get involved in peer review, says Sarah Blackford, a career adviser with the Society for Experimental Biology in London. (nature.com)

Do men favour men and women favour women when they peer review each other's work? (thenakedscientists.com)
Open review (where both author and reviewer know each other's names) is a better option, as it increases ethical responsibility on both sides. (editage.com)

You may wish to review the privacy policy of the external site as its information collection practices may differ from ours. (cpsc.gov)
Other than that, the peer review practices have not changed over those 4 years. (historians.org)
However, peer-review practices also are based, at least to some extent, on the cultural and behavioral practices of the peer-review group performing the evaluations. (domesticpreparedness.com)

NIOSH/OEP adapted quickly to move from in-person peer review meetings to online review meetings. (cdc.gov)
NIOSH was able to conduct the WTCHP meeting using the Virtual Meeting (VM) module within the NIH Internet Assisted Review (IAR) system, which was already in use for data collection in face-to-face meetings. (cdc.gov)
Michael Goldcamp, PhD, is the Review Team Lead in the NIOSH Office of Extramural Programs. (cdc.gov)
Their comments compose an interesting commentary on TWH as NIOSH continues to implement this promising, but still young, national program intended to provide the research foundation to assist employers and employees realize the tremendous opportunity for a healthier and more productive workforce. (cdc.gov)

That is the real peer review: not all these silly processes that go on before and immediately after publication," he said. (timeshighereducation.com)
The overall objectives of the IPCS are to establish the scientific basis for assessment of the risk to human health and the environment from exposure to chemicals, through international peer review processes, as a prerequisite for the promotion of chemical safety, and to provide technical assistance in strengthening national capacities for the sound management of chemicals. (inchem.org)
Also, the objectives are supported by participating in the process of producing scientific knowledge through participating in conferences, peer review processes, publication work and the production of a thesis. (lu.se)

A new survey of over 12,000 peer-reviewed climate science papers by our citizen science team at Skeptical Science has found a 97% consensus among papers taking a position on the cause of global warming in the peer-reviewed literature that humans are responsible. (skepticalscience.com)
We performed a keyword search of peer-reviewed scientific journal publications (in the ISI Web of Science) for the terms 'global warming' and 'global climate change' between the years 1991 and 2011, which returned over 12,000 papers. (skepticalscience.com)
Jennifer - Well the fundamental question is whether journals when they review scientific papers are finding the best science or whether there are other factors biases that could be influencing the review process. (thenakedscientists.com)
At that time the papers had not yet been published in a peer-reviewed journal, yet the team promoted these claims to the media with the punchline that this evidence, as ABC News interpreted it, "erases the idea of human exceptionalism. (sott.net)
These reviews are extremely doubtful about the papers' claims, and multiple voices in the scientific community have been harshly critical. (sott.net)
The article quotes a paleoarchaeologist who reviewed one of the eLife papers, stating: "there just wasn't any science in the paper ultimately. (sott.net)
The papers' peer reviews, posted on 12 July, come to much the same conclusion about the scientific evidence. (sott.net)
Second, some papers may be quickly reviewed by a number of readers, while others may be unduly neglected. (lse.ac.uk)
Third, as reviewing is voluntary, there is little control over whether reviewing takes place at all and the time taken for papers to be reviewed. (lse.ac.uk)
Papers are reviewed in the order in which they are submitted. (lse.ac.uk)
Whereby, their own papers will not be reviewed and their right to use the preprint database will be suspended for a period of time. (lse.ac.uk)
Meanwhile, science publisher Jan Velterop said peer review should be carried out entirely by the academy, with publishers limited to producing technically perfect, machine readable papers for a "much, much lower" fee than typical open access charges. (timeshighereducation.com)
The review process does the community a favor in making sure that these bad papers do not get published. (blogspot.com)
This only extends the delay between submission and the actual conference by 4 months --- today there is usually an 8 month delay while papers are being reviewed, and camera-ready papers are being prepared. (blogspot.com)
Sam's point #3: Eliminating the review system will discourage people from working hard on their papers. (blogspot.com)
In my short career, most of the reviews I've received have been genuinely helpful and I've published better papers because of them. (editage.com)
Graduate students generally are not recognized for their ability to conduct independent peer review unless, like Santos, they are already establishing an academic reputation by publishing first-author papers. (nature.com)

Right now, many people think peer review means, "This paper is great and trustworthy! (editage.com)

The editors at Communications Biology ran a series of posts across our Community sites for Peer Review Week all of which involved contributions from their editorial board. (springernature.com)

For the AHR , peer review helps us direct our authors to crafting articles with what we call "reach"-namely, the effort to speak beyond the confines of a particular field to a wider historical audience, even while significantly advancing the scholarship in the narrower case. (historians.org)
We need peer review because science (and scholarship generally) is a community endeavour. (editage.com)

The first step of our approach involved expanding the original survey of the peer-reviewed scientific literature in Oreskes (2004) . (skepticalscience.com)
These reports were prepared by over two thousand experts, and "contain the factual basis of the issue of climate change, gleaned from available expert literature and further carefully reviewed by experts and governments. (wikipedia.org)
Dr Charles points out that there is a limitation in using only the published literature, which is peer-reviewed, as was done in this paper. (cdc.gov)
Indeed, a much fuller picture might be developed if gray literature and internal reports of insurance companies and corporations were available for review. (cdc.gov)
The gray literature is often not peer-reviewed or easily accessible. (cdc.gov)

One of the weird aspects of climate science is the over-emphasis on peer review as the ne plus ultra guarantor of believable results. (coyoteblog.com)

At issue: The quality of reviews of research paper submissions in the database community is deteriorating rapidly. (blogspot.com)
Instead of having your paper reviewed by three people in private, every problem, every flaw in logic, every typo is immediately out there in the public for people to look at and comment on. (blogspot.com)
The paper will be assigned to a nonconflicted editorial board member who will oversee the paper through peer review and make all recommendations for the paper. (computer.org)
Even if they aren't invited, another natural first step is to review a paper jointly with seasoned colleagues or under their mentorship, says Emma Ganley, co-editor-in-chief of the journal PLoS Biology . (nature.com)
An author could make a dubious claim in a preprint that sees no editorial oversight or review, and then cite that claim as an accepted belief in the field in a subsequent published paper. (sspnet.org)
Anything that has not been peer reviewed is treated as a "personal communication" and can be referred to in the paper, but is noted as such. (sspnet.org)
Also on Ecology & Evolution, another one of our regulars Camille Delavaux considers how a paper travels through peer review and how ultimately this helps shape the final publication . (springernature.com)
A NASA spokesperson has dismissed a major critique of the Science arsenic bug paper based not on the criticism's merits, but on its venue -- it appeared in a blog rather than a peer-reviewed journal. (fieldofscience.com)
But there may be a new way: Earlier this month, Adam Day, a data scientist at SAGE Publishing, posted a preprint on arXiv that used a variety of methods to search for duplication in peer review comments, based on the likelihood that paper mills "create fake referee accounts and use them to submit fake peer-review reports. (ahrecs.com)
I welcome Dr Charles' comments because they highlight a major point made in the paper, namely that occupational disease and injury are underestimated. (cdc.gov)

One of those is the rigour of peer review, where new science is scrutinised by authorities in the field before it's accepted for publication. (thenakedscientists.com)
I recall back during Climate-gate the words "peer-reviewed" were supposed to stop all debate, as any purported science that went through peer-review was supposed to be impeccable and the "science" behind it was not to be challenged . (blogspot.com)
We are committed to continuous review of our peer review system because we know the system should evolve as the science evolves, and there are always ways to make it better. (nih.gov)
Launched last year by Sense about Science, ORCID, ScienceOpen and Wiley, Peer Review Week follows in the wake of two open letters from the academic community on the issue of peer review recognition. (oup.com)
If you believe the hype, peer review is flawed and corrupt , a broken system threatening to undermine the very foundations of academia… particularly science . (editage.com)
The Curious Wavefunction: Aliens, arsenic and alternative peer-review: Has science publishing become too conservative? (fieldofscience.com)
Aliens, arsenic and alternative peer-review: Has science publishing become too conservative? (fieldofscience.com)
All that said, I'm not sure focusing on peer-reviewed science has been helping very much. (fieldofscience.com)
Traditionally, peer review has been an idealistic endeavor performed purely for the advancement of science. (medscape.com)

This is especially the case in an era in which expectations for instant news and fast information delivery have risen, and makes it difficult if not impossible for peer-reviewed journals to address issues of the day in a timely fashion. (historians.org)

As you can imagine this enormous peer review endeavor is highly dependent on your willingness to serve. (nih.gov)

Turn on Track ChangesOpen Microsoft Word.Choose the Review tab at the top of the document.Either click the Track Changes button (PC) or toggle the Track Changes switch (Mac).Make sure that you change 'Simple Markup' to 'All Markup' from the drop down bar next to Track Changes. (draftlessig.org)
So how on earth can a study lack statistical analysis and make it through peer review? (blogspot.com)
We hope that the peer review will help make this a better health assessment. (cdc.gov)
Please use this form to submit your questions or comments on how to make this article more useful to clinicians. (medscape.com)

Peer review is the process by which outside experts in a particular subject area assess the scientific rigor, validity, and other measures of quality to determine whether a scientific article meets the standards for publication," according to Amy Drew, the APS director of publications. (psychologicalscience.org)
At best, peer review is a screen for whether a study is worthy of occupying limited publication space, not for whether it is correct. (coyoteblog.com)
Since the original publication of the story the cardiologists on the "peer review panel" have resigned and Novartis has withdrawn its support for the contest. (cardiobrief.org)
The contest is designed to support the publication of peer review articles that will support the wider use of Entresto. (cardiobrief.org)
This focus stems from the fact that while perceived as important, peer review is often regarded as a secondary activity to publication by decision makers across the Higher Education and funding sectors. (oup.com)
Indeed, Peder Olesen Larsen and Markus von Ins would argue that what makes a scientific publication a serious one, is not citation but peer review . (oup.com)
I've reviewed for open-access journal PeerJ, where they offer me the option to sign my review, and also an incentive (a free publication) if I finish the review in 10 days. (editage.com)
Here, we provide the information you need to oversee peer review as an editor for an IEEE Computer Society publication. (computer.org)
Last week saw the publication of the second part of Professor Dame Carol Black's Independent Review of Drugs. (hepctrust.org.uk)
Their background experience will help them to carry out the key components of peer review: they must be able to assess whether work is new to the field and original enough to deserve publication - and by the journal in question. (nature.com)
The Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (ATSDR), a federal public health agency of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, announced that publication of its Public Health Assessment of Kelly Air Force Base, in San Antonio, Texas, has been postponed so that the document can undergo peer review. (cdc.gov)
The agency then reviews the comments, responds in writing, and proceeds with publication of the health assessment or makes appropriate changes. (cdc.gov)
Peer review is an essential component of the publication process. (medscape.com)

Now in its second year, Peer Review Week is focusing on the issue of Peer Review recognition, its current coordinating committee including additional organisations such as AAAS, COPE, eLife, and the Royal Society and the Federation of European Microbiological Societies (FEMS). (oup.com)
It seems we need a review committee at least for that. (blogspot.com)
Scientific Program Committee, which performed peer review. (cdc.gov)

Comments on Medscape are moderated and should be professional in tone and on topic. (medscape.com)

Dr. Richard Nakamura is director of the NIH Center for Scientific Review . (nih.gov)
Last year we highlighted a new section of the NIH Data Book that provides statistics about peer review across NIH, including peer review organized by the Center of Scientific Review as well as peer review organized by NIH institutes and centers. (nih.gov)
Scientific Review. (oup.com)

A written review usually follows a certain structure that helps the editor to ultimately answer the question: Should this particular article be published in this particular journal? (psychologicalscience.org)
Has there been any change in the way peer review has been conducted at the AHR in your time associated with the journal? (historians.org)
The journal eLife has a unique peer-review publishing model. (sott.net)
However, no peer reviewed journal in the field will publish his work. (coyoteblog.com)
Seriously, though, an actual peer-reviewed journal is publishing material from little kids now? (blogspot.com)
He said peer review persists due to "huge vested interests", and admitted that scrapping peer review was "just too bold a step" for a journal editor currently to take. (timeshighereducation.com)
The Australasian Philosophical Review is the AAP's new open peer commentary journal. (aap.org.au)
They might then get invited by the journal to conduct the review. (nature.com)

Other editorial board roles that do not oversee peer review, such as department editors, are described in the EIC Manual Section 2.A . Editors are selected on the basis of their expertise in one of the domains within the publication's scope and by their professional standing in the community as supported by bibliometric indices or other available evaluative metrics. (computer.org)

The Hepatitis C Trust's submission to Professor Dame Carol Black's consultation highlighted that peers with lived experience of hepatitis C have a key role to play in education around harm reduction and in achieving health and recovery outcomes, by awareness-raising, tackling stigma and influencing care pathways. (hepctrust.org.uk)
The success of the hepatitis C peer model in improving engagement with testing and treatment among marginalised groups is testament to the positive outcomes peer support can deliver. (hepctrust.org.uk)

I think this is one of the main challenges peer review faces. (historians.org)

In honor of Peer Review Week , Alex and I had an email exchange regarding some of his thoughts on peer review. (historians.org)

Peer review "is one of the most important things we do as scholars," Tone said. (psychologicalscience.org)
Now some humanities scholars have begun to challenge the monopoly that peer review has on admission to career-making journals and, as a consequence, to the charmed circle of tenured academe. (scienceblogs.com)

It's a view echoed in the preliminary findings of one of two new surveys on peer review, the first released by FEMS as part of this week's activities, which reveals that, at least among the global microbiology community, authors subject to peer review perceive greater professional development benefits from the process than do the people carrying out the reviews. (oup.com)

However, without being peer reviewed they serve a limited function, as they are often not recognised as high quality research publications. (lse.ac.uk)
However good and fair the peer review process is, the reality is that we receive far more high quality applications than we could ever support. (nih.gov)
Yesterday my former PhD advisor, Sam Madden, wrote a blog post consisting of a passionate defense for the status quo in the peer review process (though he does say that the review quality needs to be improved). (blogspot.com)
It also works better than incentives to increase the quality of the review. (editage.com)
The meeting successfully provided a high-quality review of the 35 applications. (cdc.gov)
To address the challenge of managing these large meetings virtually, OEP initiated the use of multiple panels to complete high quality reviews in a timely manner and reduce peer reviewer burden. (cdc.gov)
Peer review comments augment diagnostic error characterization and departmental quality assurance: 1-year experience from a children's hospital. (bvsalud.org)
The objective of our study was to categorize radiologist peer review comments and evaluate their functions within the context of a comprehensive quality assurance (QA) program. (bvsalud.org)
Why is peer review such a poor quality control mechanism? (ox.ac.uk)

Having fought for over a year to keep the information secret, the DWP have finally been forced by the Information Commissioner to reveal that claimants on the work programme were among the 49 people whose deaths were peer reviewed by the DWP. (benefitsandwork.co.uk)
How many of the 49 claimants whose deaths were peer reviewed were ESA claimants who were, or had recently been, on the work programme? (benefitsandwork.co.uk)
In the case that a long absence is necessary, the editor must establish a means for their work as an editor to continue effectively, and the peer review administrator must be provided with full contact information as the editor moves from one location to another. (computer.org)
When clinical treatment and public health are involved, extra care must be taken to ensure that it is clear to the reader that the work being described has not been peer reviewed. (sspnet.org)
Peer Review: Work or Hobby? (medscape.com)
Cite this: Peer Review: Work or Hobby? (medscape.com)
If you have been asked to peer review another student's text as part of course work, check the instructions that you have received, as there may be other aspects that need to be taken into consideration than the ones listed below. (lu.se)

Please read our commenting and letters policy before submitting. (historians.org)
In order to get an overview of the text you have been asked to review, read it through, marking only things that stand out and that you will take a closer look at later on. (lu.se)

You must be logged in to post a comment. (uncommondescent.com)

This ensures that each submission can be tracked properly, will receive a fair and unbiased review, and is handled in an efficient and timely manner. (computer.org)

We believe that the proposed changes to standards for performing and reporting on peer reviews would mitigate many of the issues identified by the AICPA in its recent analysis of matters for further consideration in peer review engagements. (gao.gov)

While writing a review, "context is key," Drew explained. (psychologicalscience.org)
Peer input is essential to put the article's findings into context for the reader. (medscape.com)

As the editor of the AHR , what do you see as the primary purposes of peer review? (historians.org)
Understanding the peer-review process begins with the recognition that every funding agency, whether public or private, has a specific mission in mind (several missions, in fact, much of the time) - and improving the capability of carrying out that mission is the primary basis for awarding grant funds. (domesticpreparedness.com)

Be explicit about the process (presentation round, roles, peer review. (lu.se)

Each September, the international scientific community takes the opportunity to recognize the importance of peer review to the scientific process. (biophysics.org)
There are three obvious weak points to Community Peer Review. (lse.ac.uk)
As one part of the process of building the system for submission and processing of these proposals, the APR is calling for people to join its open peer commentary community. (aap.org.au)
Peer review is a community service, not a commodity. (editage.com)
As an academic, peer review is a way of giving back to the community that helped you build your own career. (editage.com)
Regular Contributor Juliano Morimoto compares the peer review process to Greek mythology on the Ecology & Evolution Community, and shares his experience as an author, reviewer and editor from the perspective of an early career researcher. (springernature.com)
and back to the Ecology & Evolution Community with Dominique Morneau on the future of peer review . (springernature.com)
Community members seeking information on the procedures of the health assessment or the peer review process should contact ATSDR Health Assessor Dr. David Fowler, toll free, at 1-800-447-1544. (cdc.gov)

A penalty mechanism for if an author or reviewer does not accept a review assignment, or does not complete review on time. (lse.ac.uk)
Focusing on peer review as a mechanism for establishing authority is convenient, because the public (thinks it) understands the mechanisms. (fieldofscience.com)

Adam Day (AD): This all started when an eagle-eyed editor at SAGE Publishing noticed that 2 different referees had left identical comments on 2 different peer-reviews. (ahrecs.com)

Organisms5

Diseases1

Chemicals and Drugs1

Analytical, Diagnostic and Therapeutic Techniques and Equipment19

Psychiatry and Psychology77

Phenomena and Processes4

Disciplines and Occupations9

Anthropology, Education, Sociology and Social Phenomena64

Technology, Industry, Agriculture6

Humanities6

Information Science28

Named Groups12

Health Care105

Publication Characteristics1

Geographicals3

Reviewers33

20167

20201

Manuscript5

Basics of Peer Review1

Manuscripts7

Scientists6

Explained the peer-review process1

Preprint servers2

Forms of peer review3

Process of peer review1

Retraction Watch1

Thoughtful2

Preprints6

Reviewer's3

Shakespeare Quarterly2

Responses3

Scholarly4

Content3

Role of peer1

Insights1

Report4

Draft3

Evaluation4

Researchers3

Other's2

Practices3

NIOSH4

Processes3

Papers17

Trustworthy1

Contributions1

Scholarship2

Literature5

Climate science1

Paper10

Science9

News1

Endeavor1

Make4

Publication13

Committee3

Medscape1

Scientific Review3

Journal8

Editorial1

Outcomes2

Main1

Thoughts1

Scholars2

Microbiology1

Quality9

Work7

Read2

Post1

Timely manner1

Consideration1

Context2

Primary2

Roles1

Community8

Mechanism2

Referees1